WoWDB

IMPORTANT: Achievement cannot be earned outside of Winter Veil even if your character knows the recipes and has the necessary materials.

Characters will require a minimum Cooking skill level of 325 in order to earn the achievement. (Cooking doesn't require any minimum level in order to learn the next cooking level, so this achievement is possible for even a Level 1 character to earn... if you're willing to put work into it.)

•  Recipe: Gingerbread Cookie (Cooking skill 1)
•  Small Egg x 1
•  Holiday Spices x 1

•  Recipe: Winter Veil Eggnog (Cooking skill 35)
•  Small Egg x 1
•  Ice Cold Milk x 1
•  Holiday Spirits x 1
•  Holiday Spices x 1

•  Recipe: Hot Apple Cider (Cooking skill 325)
•  Sparkling Apple Cider x 1
•  Holiday Spirits x 1
•  Holiday Spices x 1

Total mats needed:

•  Small Egg x 2
•  Holiday Spirits x 2
•  Holiday Spices x 3
•  Ice Cold Milk x 1
•  Sparkling Apple Cider x 1